Ok straight off I know everyone will have different feelings about this. Now I by nature am submissive so you would assume I would find the Dominant girl more attractive. However discovering just how submissive my wife was and the fact she would never have won a fight just made her even hotter to me. (OK it was her reaction to the idea of fighting and losing and being humiliated which was so hot and she was soooo turned on by the idea).
In pro wrestling though I used to love the days of an overmatched young face against the more mature, larger heel. I even enjoyed the days of Glow watching one of my faves Ninotchka defeat the faces.
Its not purely about finding the Jobber more attractive though, there have been tons of matches where the dominant winner became more attractive because they won.
I do love one sided matches with a clear winner who is preferably a heel and a decimated loser who is hopefully a cute young jobber.