[wheelman]

The two are rumored to have had an icy relationship in the past. What happens when things come to a head?

Carrie Underwood 39yo, 5'5 - 120lbs                                                              Kelly Clarkson 40yo 5'3 - 150lbs

[Firefly]

Interesting match up. I see the uber fit Carrie making short work of a chubby and relatively out of shape Kelly Clarkson in this one.

[Leslieinvegas]

Carrie works out and hubby a hockey player. Carrie toys with chubby Kelly like a cat with a mouse than takes Kelly out with a brutal upper cut.

LL

[bunny]

Kelly will be beaten up badly by Carrie

[wheelman]

Voting and comments all heavily in Carrie's favor. I can definitely see a scenario where Kelly's big mouth starts an altercation between the two before being treated to a one sided thrashing at the hands of a much fitter and more athletic Carrie Underwood.