Nancy just smiled. She turned to me and told me to “clean her up” and bring her with me to the boudoir. I told her we weren’t having sex, and that I didn’t care what the rules were. She just smiled, winked at me, and told her to meet her in there anyways, she said she had a gift for me. Then she left.
I quickly got a medical supply kit that was in the weight room and began to tend to Tina’s wounds. She was in really bad shape having sustained grievous wounds. Nothing life threatening, but her once perfect face was a complete mess. It had looked as if she had been then victim of a badly abusive husband. As I tended to her she started to regain consciousness. I had asked her if she meant what she had said before. She said she meant everything, except for telling me I could fuck Nancy. She said Nancy always beat her in everything in life, that was completely true. She’d always get all the attention and all the boys she wanted, even Tina’s husband. However, she said I was the first thing she wanted that she couldn’t have. She said she knew Nancy was stronger than her before agreeing to the fight, but she didn’t care because she had to fight for me. I meant everything to her, and she’d do anything for me. I was so flattered, I could barely express how much she meant to me. Tina said that she could take her husband, her pride, and even her body, but that no matter what she couldn’t take me and that’s all that matter to her.
After I tended to Tina I helped her into the bedroom and let her sit down in one of the chairs. She was still very weak and could barely speak at all, after talking to me. We waited in the room for Nancy until she finally came in the room. When she entered she asked me to leave to ready the “surprise”.
When I walked back in Tina was bound to the chair with her one good eye taped open. Just as I was about to demand her be released I saw Nancy on the bed, completely naked. I didn’t have chance to fully appreciate her body during the fight because I was so worried about Tina, but I was just completely blown away seeing her nude for the first time. She easily had the best body I’ve ever seen. She got up from bed and walked towards me. We immediately started kissing and then she took her lips slowly down my body until she reached my penis. She then proceeded to give me a blow job, something Tina had never done for me. It felt phenomenal and I was in complete ecstasy. For a moment I made eye contact with Tina, but I just couldn’t bear to look at her after what I said to her. I could see the disappointment in her eye, I could feel the disappointment.
But no matter how hard I tried I couldn’t resist Nancy. It didn’t take me long to get hard again after she sucked me dry and we took it to the bed and had the most hot, rough, aggressive, and crazy sex I’ve ever had. It was nothing like with Tina. Everything was spontaneous. Nancy was a goddess in bed, and even allowed me to experiment with anal. It was easily the best sexual experience I’ve ever had.
When we were finished Nancy let Tina leave. I could see she felt horrified and betrayed, and I felt terrible, but I just couldn’t give up Nancy. She had completely changed the way I felt about sex.
When Tina left I turned to Nancy to see if she was ready for “round 2” but she declined my offer and asked me to leave. Confused I asked why, and she responded by telling me that all the “orgasms” she experienced while we just had sex were for show, in order to rub it in Tina’s face. She said she had to make the sex seem enjoyable to make Tina feel bad.
I asked Nancy what was so wrong with me in bed. She said, point blank, that my penis was far too tiny for her to be pleasured by. She told me I had a “4 inch chode” and that she pitied me. She said it was the first penis she’s even been able to fit in her mouth completely. She said no “real woman” would ever want to have sex with me because of my small dick. After hearing this I was so embarrassed / ashamed I left immediately.
I’ve tried to rekindle things with Tina, but she won’t even interact with me outside of family functions. The one time I did manage to talk to her she said what had happened left her emotionally scarred forever.
What do you guys think? Do I deserve to get Tina back after what I did, or was I only honoring the bet that was made before the match?
Any ideas on how I might be able to win her back again?
