[T aka Tony]

Both are smokin hottt, both are Idols, who will win this NHB Catfight, Carrie Underwood or Katharine McPhee? You decide.

[iamrodgers]

This is a great match up! Katherine is too much for Carrie stripping her before making her submit in tears.

[JimmyBondi]

Carrie is wondering why she ever thought she had a chance agaist Katharine.

Katharine will shredder her in little pieces.

[wheelman]

Katherine makes short work of Cream puff Carrie.