[Freefall]

[Freefall]

I will write story based on outcome

[Jackflash Jump]

I cast my vote for 'Other', and that other would be the Russian Nightmare herself...

[psubill]

Kim will take the title by overpowering Scarlett using her best ASSet!

[Rachel the Catfighter]

I vote for ME .... she is definitely one of my celebrity dream fights, but of the choices you gave I say Kim (another one of my dream fights, lol)

[Jebediah Morningside]

I'd go with Kaley Cuoco, but I also like the idea of Anna Kournikova listed above. 

-JM

[GoldenGirl]

Well, Kim has endured quite a lot of stick over the past year or so; and, as we approach the "Season of Goodwill", I thought it would be rather lovely if she had some GOOD news - not that she would necessarily be aware of it!

GG

[blahblahblah]

Tough choice between Megan Fox and Kim Kardashian! Megan seems much more brutal than Scarlett and would simply overpower her. But the thought of big-titted Scarlett squashed beneath Kim's massive ass is very tempting as well...

I think I go with Kim! Kim drops her ass onto Scarlett's tits until they're flat as pancakes and then finished the blonde off with a head-engulfing face-sit!

[nyanderson]

scarlett have no match opponent to fight her,I think she's the best
but If I must choose I think Kate Upton is good match againts Scarlett

[IRISH]

Other.... Karen McDougal

[Amy-n-Mark]

Mark says L Lo...but I voted for Kim K.  Kim wins with that wicked bum but mocks Scarlett by giving her a breast smother to finish her.
I like this "worst nightmare" idea... 

[jonny22]

Jennifer love Hewitt to kick Scarlett's ass.

http://www.hdwallpapersdj.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/KIIS-FM-Jingle-Ball-in-LA-3-12-2011-jennifer-love-hewitt-27718108-1938-2560.jpg

[Freefall]

I figure each challenger has her own "weapon" that could end Scarlett's reign...

Lohans juggs conquering Scarlett's rack and then devouring her face




Kim's ass swallowing Scarlett whole




and Megan sinking her bitchy claws into a shocked Scarlett

[Ginny38]

IF the criteria is "shockingly losing her title" then I can't imagine that any of the three women offered in vote would be more "SHOCKING" than Lindsay Lohan (assuming she can get/stay clean and sober long enough to pull it off!)

Both KK and Fox clean up nicely and you can almost see them being 'tough enuf' to beat up cute little Miss Johansson...unlike Lohan. So that's why LL gets my vote as "the most shocking" upset.

If you want an "other" - I see Kournikova (or even Hewitt) as being somewhat more shocking than either Kim/Megan (given Anna's "loser rep" and Hewitt's "goody girl" image.

Personally, I'd love to read a story of Charlize Theron taking Scarlett to the woodshed, but that would definitely NOT be an upset - which is the thrust of this thread!

[lone ranger]

carol kirkwood