I also love the optics of a redhead vs redhead catfight, and I have all three of these, as I am a big Jolene fan. Here is my 2 cents.
All three were very good to excellent based on my preferences, and I would rank them as follows:
1 - Cheyenne vs Jolene. I was surprised that Cheyenne would actually do more catfighting than wrestling, but maybe thats because Jolene brought more of the bith out of her. I didnt know Cheyenne had it in her, and I really enjoiyed this fight. If you were going to buy just one I would pick this one.
2 - Sarah vs Jolene. I loved this fight even though it ended prematurely. The interviews with the ladies explains the ending (the fight is stopped before the two ladies could be injured), but I still liked the raw action. I really hope there is a rematch because I don't think this fight really settled on a winner.
3 - Sarah vs Cheyenne. For fans of belly punching in a catfight this is a good pick. I enjoy it, so I liked the fight. Probably more wrestling with hairpulling and belly punching than a catfight, but the fight was still a very good fight. Two ladies with hot bodies IMO.
Don't know if this helps at all, but Jolene and Sarah and Cheyenne are all beautiful and all excellent fighters in their own way.