[Jessica92]

Xenia Tchoumitcheva




Emma Watson

[YumiReiko]

Emma All the Way! She's real cute champion! XDDD

[Jessica92]

I am puzzled as to how to intepret the result of this poll. Technically speaking, the Xenia crushes Emma result has got the most votes, but all in all, if we sum the votes for Xenia and the votes for Emma it turns out there are more votes for Emma winning than for Xenia winning. So maybe this poll means Emma wins. I should run another poll perhaps.

[CFreferee]

i think its impossible that Emma defeats Xenia, Xenia is not very strongh but she is heavier and way fitter than Emma, this is not a personal opinion, is a fact

[Ginny38]

If you give 2 pts for a "crush" vote - it being a more decisive outcome - and 1 pt for a "barely" vote you can justify one result.  
Emma (16x2=32 + 13 totals 45) vs Xenia (19x2=38 + 7 totals 45) therefore a DRAW!

But If you go strictly by total votes for, you get a different result: Emma (16+13 = 29) vs Xenia (19+7 = 26) therefore EMMA wins!

Whatever you do (and I think another vote - with possibly different result choices? - would be the fairest) but IF SO, you should state how the votes will be evaluated... perhaps by giving a certain "weight" to a more decisive finish.... or let voters choose HOW the fight ends, (and again you could weight the choices, i.e., 5 for a KO/pin vote... 3 for a submission and 1 for a judges decision FOR EXAMPLE)

That way, voters could (or might not) consider how strongly they feel a particular outcome is likely.....

Now, I suppose I've just further confused you about what to do (grin!)

[CFreferee]

we need a rematch!

[Jebediah Morningside]

IMO, the girl who gets the most "win" votes should be the winner unless it's stated at the poll's outset that the votes will be tallied in some other way.   Just my opinion. 

-JM

[GramerJew123]

Yea, pretty sure Emma won. But if you want to do a rematch, I don't think anyone would mind.

[Marvelcatfights]

I have been busy lately and have not checked in for a while.  For what it is worth, I would have voted for Xenia.

[Jessica92]

Ok, I have decided.
I officially declare Emma Watson the winner of this fight.
Cheers for Emma!