Hot! Hot! Hot! Void, you have outdone yourself. Those are absolutely great pictures and a great idea for a sexy catfight. Boy! this is a hard choice.
I believe that both of these gals are fighters. Brooke is probably the more athletic of the two but Carmen may be, pound for pound, stronger. When Brooke was one "Wild On", she tried just about everything from rock climbing to sky driving. She certainly had no fear, or if she did, she concealed it well. She never had a stand-in so I give her a 10 as being someone who would try anything once. She may be too much of a lady to start a fight but, if Carmen called her out, she would not walk away. I have no doubt that she would mix it up with the best of them.
Carmen, on the other hand, is no push over. I believe that she is a little toughie and would not let the big girl push her around. While not necessaryily athletic in terms of participating in sports, she is a competitor and I believe that her competitiveness would carry over to a catfight. Carmen claims that she keeps in shape by running and working out 2 hours a day, 5 times a week at a gym. Those terrific pictures of Carmen would suggest that she is in top shape and ready to rumble with Brooke. I believe that it would be a long and intense down and dirty fight where both women end up naked within seconds of the start. In the end, however, I believe that Brooke would probably end up on top with an exhausted Carmen pinned beneath her. With both women too exhausted to continue, Carmen will not submit to Brooke despite being unable to break the pin. Brooke, in frustration, unable to apply an effective breast smother, holds the pin for a full 5 minutes and then rises holding Carmen's bikini top high in victory. I see a rematch in the near future.
