Lindsay Lohan vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar

[Beaufait]

Redhead vs. Blonde. Who wins?

[CrashCorrigan]

Here's a match where I think Lindsay has a real chance against mousy-faced beauty Sarah Michelle Gellar.  This is one where the tops should be ripped off, leading to a world-class titfight between big-boobed Lindsay and smaller-boobed Sarah.  The mind boggles!  I'm picking Lindsay for the win.

[Amy-n-Mark]

Lindsay will rock her!  lol

[Mindcastle]

I agree. Sarah does not have a chance against a street tough Lindsay.  Lindsay loves to fight.

[Nancycat]

Lindsay will win!Sarah is so weak.................

[fantasyman]

I totally disagree with the majority here! Usually I am part of the majority but not on this one. Sarah Michelle Gellar is a trained fighter in both martial arts and kick boxing. She is not weak at all. She is very fit, fast and really knows how to fight irl. I don't think Lindsay is as tough as people think. She is a drug addict and a failure who's body is breaking down. I would think she would have very little strength and even less coordination. My vote is for Sarah Michelle Gellar to wipe the floor with Lindsay.

[Marvelcatfights]

I go with the majority.  Lindsay will defeat Sarah Michelle.

[steph]

smg is to good for lohan to deal with

[JT Edson]

I vote for Sarah. She has had training to fight (Buffy the Vampire Slayer).

[MistressVicky]

Lindsay punches Sarah until Sarah is bloody, crying, blubbering mess and then she makes Sarah her slave.

[Vassago]

Apparently Gellar has been training karate or something like that. If Lohan turns up drunk as usual she'll be knocked out in less than ten seconds 

[rozczochrany]

Sarah Michelle Gellar would win.

[de Trixah]

I take Lindsay to win this.

[Jebediah Morningside]

I think Lindsay has a certain amount of street smarts and probably toughened up a bit in jail, but Sarah is certainly in better shape and has legitimate training in martial arts.  Lindsay does have some size advantage, of course.  I think the bottom line is that IF Lindsay is sober and together she'd have a reasonable chance of winning, particularly if it was a street fight scenario.  However, if she's out-of-shape and strung out, Sarah would almost certainly take her apart.  In short, the circumstances of the battle would pretty much determine the outcome.

-JM

[JT Edson]

I think Lindsay has a certain amount of street smarts and probably toughened up a bit in jail, but Sarah is certainly in better shape and has legitimate training in martial arts.  Lindsay does have some size advantage, of course.  I think the bottom line is that IF Lindsay is sober and together she'd have a reasonable chance of winning, particularly if it was a street fight scenario.  However, if she's out-of-shape and strung out, Sarah would almost certainly take her apart.  In short, the circumstances of the battle would pretty much determine the outcome.

-JM

I'll buy that.

[JT Edson]