When reading a fight that someone has written, what kind of fight do you prefer?

Started by Golden Goddess, April 15, 2019, 04:07:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Golden Goddess

Topic title. Just a little poll I thought I'd put together before doing more writing. :)

What kind of fight stories do you enjoy reading the most, in terms of it being an even match compared to a squash? How much of a dominant win do you prefer to see in fights that other people have written? How one-sided do you like things to be? Does it depend on the competitors?

Celebrity Strapon Queen

Depends on the competition to me, but I also like it when a domme is winning and then gets shocked and is humiliated

herboyfriend

This thread is for celebrity fight polls, not for general questions in form of polls!
Every excess is fine as long as you don't overdo it.

prettiestmommy93

Quote from: herboyfriend on April 15, 2019, 07:43:33 AM
This thread is for celebrity fight polls, not for general questions in form of polls!
there's really no where else to put it though.
I feel like it's fine.

Golden Goddess

Quote from: herboyfriend on April 15, 2019, 07:43:33 AM
This thread is for celebrity fight polls, not for general questions in form of polls!

If polls were allowed in Celeb Fight - General, I would have put it there.

If it's a problem I'll close the poll and move on. :shrug:

WriteThisWay

Quote from: herboyfriend on April 15, 2019, 07:43:33 AM
This thread is for celebrity fight polls, not for general questions in form of polls!

Go make 83 more Katy Perry polls then.

ayaan

Close fights are the best. There's a thrill  that anyone can win and that feeling of not knowing who would win in a close fight is unmatchable

herboyfriend

Quote from: WriteThisWay on April 15, 2019, 04:56:47 PM
Quote from: herboyfriend on April 15, 2019, 07:43:33 AM
This thread is for celebrity fight polls, not for general questions in form of polls!

Go make 83 more Katy Perry polls then.
I'm working on 87!
Every excess is fine as long as you don't overdo it.

eyeinthesky

Quote from: Golden Goddess on April 15, 2019, 04:07:58 AM
What kind of fight stories do you enjoy reading the most, in terms of it being an even match compared to a squash? How much of a dominant win do you prefer to see in fights that other people have written? How one-sided do you like things to be? Does it depend on the competitors?

it depends on who are fighting and how. also it depends very much on the writing skills of the writer. if they're not able to be descriptive I don't bother. also I'd say always list the names of the celebs involved in the story. most of the time I don't click those titles that just say Big breasts stars do battle or something

Golden Goddess

Quote from: eyeinthesky on April 19, 2019, 12:12:35 AM
it depends on who are fighting and how. also it depends very much on the writing skills of the writer. if they're not able to be descriptive I don't bother. also I'd say always list the names of the celebs involved in the story. most of the time I don't click those titles that just say Big breasts stars do battle or something

A thousand times this. It drives me crazy when people don't put the names of the fighters in the title. Lol.

Interested fightfan

A close match, but it's obvious who the winner is going to be. The loser puts up a strong fight, but it's telling from the start that she won't win.

herboyfriend

Nobody has explained yet in which way this is a celebrity poll fight, and why this is still here?
Every excess is fine as long as you don't overdo it.

Ginny38

Quote from: herboyfriend on April 20, 2019, 12:21:59 PM
Nobody has explained yet in which way this is a celebrity poll fight, and why this is still here?

While the QUESTION isn't "celebrity specific" it asks what kind of fight you prefer reading.... which can apply equally to celebrity AND non-celebrity fights. Personally, I don't see any reason why it SHOULDN'T be here, since there's a reasonable likelihood many readers of the celebrity thread might not read other fight threads. Also, the poster indicated he/she may post celebrity stories here and is asking for help in writing them.

Seems more like a "no harm, no foul" to me. (If the administrators disagree with me, it won't be the first time...or last either!) Just stating an OPINION.

catfightlover40

Quote from: Ginny38 on April 20, 2019, 02:56:44 PM
Quote from: herboyfriend on April 20, 2019, 12:21:59 PM
Nobody has explained yet in which way this is a celebrity poll fight, and why this is still here?

While the QUESTION isn't "celebrity specific" it asks what kind of fight you prefer reading.... which can apply equally to celebrity AND non-celebrity fights. Personally, I don't see any reason why it SHOULDN'T be here, since there's a reasonable likelihood many readers of the celebrity thread might not read other fight threads. Also, the poster indicated he/she may post celebrity stories here and is asking for help in writing them.

Seems more like a "no harm, no foul" to me. (If the administrators disagree with me, it won't be the first time...or last either!) Just stating an OPINION.

Nice and dandy, except that ignores the "YouTube creator" effect. In short, it describes channels from back in the day when Google didn't care if non-family friendly content could be monetized so a bunch of clickbait started to pop up to capitalize on a trend. The "harm" here is that there are no shortcuts to establishing a style writers usually spend years to create. The question is vague because it both targets what readers like, but also suggests the emulation of a certain style that can border on plagiarism, that authors ideally should never strive for.

My reason not to read many celebrity stories is due to the lack of studying a person's actual character, that makes it a story featuring a celebrity "as seen on TV". In the '90s, writing that Naomi Campbell would go and rough up someone wasn't an outlandish idea, it's pretty well reported how many court cases her short temper brought her, and that cannot or rather shouldn't be copied onto a different celebrity. Ideally writing isn't just a technical process, and that works best if one's voice has been found.
The  home of my multi-part work: https://www.patreon.com/powelltothepeople

Golden Goddess

Quote from: herboyfriend on April 20, 2019, 12:21:59 PM
Nobody has explained yet in which way this is a celebrity poll fight, and why this is still here?

Because you can't start polls in the Celebrity Fight - General board.

Look, I started the thread so I can see what people's tastes are like, so I can tailor my writing towards what other people would like to see, but if it's really aggravating you that much, I'll just lock the poll and ask a moderator to delete the thread.

I really don't get why you have such a grudge against this single thread when no one else seems to have issue with it. :/