[Attaguy]

Back in the day, I used to love imagining Playboy Playmates getting into catfights. (I still do but there aren’t any new playmates anymore). The girls were hot and Playboy provided their vital statistics so I could match girls with similar age and size.

Some of my favorite matchups were:

Nancy Cameron (1/74) vs Daina House (1/76)
Gig Gangel (1/80) vs Karen Price (1/81)
Kelly Tough (10/81) vs Tracy Vaccaro (10/83)
Kimberly McArthur (1/82) vs Shannon Long (10/88)
Kym Malin (5/82) vs Rebecca Ferratti (6/87)
Lynne Austin (7/87) vs Ava Fabian (8/87)
Donna Edmondson (11/87) vs Traci Adell (7/94)
Tawny Cable (6/89) vs Lisa Matthews (4/90)
Samantha Dorman (9/91) vs Becky DelosSantos (4/94)
Barbara Moore (12/92) vs Kelly Monaco (4/97)
Christi Shake (5/02) vs Aliya Wolf (2/04)

Anyone out there share this fantasy? If so, what were some of your favorite matchups?

[VAKris]

Back in the day, I used to love imagining Playboy Playmates getting into catfights. (I still do but there aren’t any new playmates anymore). The girls were hot and Playboy provided their vital statistics so I could match girls with similar age and size.

Some of my favorite matchups were:

Nancy Cameron (1/74) vs Daina House (1/76)
Gig Gangel (1/80) vs Karen Price (1/81)
Kelly Tough (10/81) vs Tracy Vaccaro (10/83)
Kimberly McArthur (1/82) vs Shannon Long (10/88)
Kym Malin (5/82) vs Rebecca Ferratti (6/87)
Lynne Austin (7/87) vs Ava Fabian (8/87)
Donna Edmondson (11/87) vs Traci Adell (7/94)
Tawny Cable (6/89) vs Lisa Matthews (4/90)
Samantha Dorman (9/91) vs Becky DelosSantos (4/94)
Barbara Moore (12/92) vs Kelly Monaco (4/97)
Christi Shake (5/02) vs Aliya Wolf (2/04)

Anyone out there share this fantasy? If so, what were some of your favorite matchups?

Lot of great match-ups in there.  Some others to consider:

     Stacy Arthur vs Cynthia Brooks

     Donna Edmondson vs Terri Welles

     Jenny McCarthy vs Erika Eleniak

     Patty McGuire vs Sondra Theodore

     Sondra Theodore vs Barbie Benton (not a Playmate but she did a couple photo shoots)

 

[Anon]

I'm not a big follower of playboy, but it's a good way to quickly get a big group of competitors that feel connected enough to be in the same league. I knew a guy who ran mass battle games and always had an easy time filling up the double digit sized teams with era specific playmates.

[IRISH]

I’m thinking of two beautiful Playmates from the late 90’s… One brunette, one blonde. They went back to back in consecutive months as PMOM, and back to back as PMOY.

The wheels are turning, but now if the spigot will open and allow the creative juices to flow…

[VAKris]

I’m thinking of two beautiful Playmates from the late 90’s… One brunette, one blonde. They went back to back in consecutive months as PMOM, and back to back as PMOY.

The wheels are turning, but now if the spigot will open and allow the creative juices to flow…

Maybe Karen McDougal (Dec 1997) and Heather Kozar (Jan 1998)?   Be a great battle.

[dash91]

Jamie Westenhiser (5/05) vs Carmella Decesare (4/03 & PotY 04)

[npom]

Roberta Vazquez (Nov. 84) vs Karen Price (Jan. 81).  Roberta thoroughly dominates Karen.

[pingpong]

Agree.

[dixonotto8]

what do you guys think about this idea.. the loser of each fight gets fed to an absolute meathead of a woman like the ones pictured below for a 5 minute beatdown.. would add a little extra motivation and would make the fights better..

[Flamingo]

Always expected pamela anderson to end up doing porn or catfighting post Baywatch

[Dario]

Erika Eleniak vs Pamela Anderson, top rivalry.

[Texaskid]

Rebecca Ferratti has told me she is the most athletic playmate.