Certainly is very close for most things, I think Ashley is a bit better looking but that is just a matter of opinion. For the titfight I went based on the first picture which shows Hudgens with a much better rack. I gave the catfight to Venessa too as I think she has a much more aggressive attitude that would help her although in the sexfight I went for Ashley, I just think her slightly longer limbs would give her good control over Hudgens when they got down to the floor.