Cecil,
At the heart there is still physical conflict between women. And if you show the layperson a video of two women slapping each other or pulling each others hair and contend its not violent, you will likely get looks of disbelief. Likewise the very phrase "female combat". Like it or not violent action is linked to the fetish, real or staged.
And I hope you didn't take me as saying these stigmas I mentioned are fact. I have met some FvsF fans that scare the fuck out of me, just as I met some that are completely harmless and well adjusted. And yes I agree, this can be a haven for people more into "women getting beat up" than "women fighting" Sadly this is the image a lot of people seem to have of the fetish. Try telling the general public FvsF fans didn't like Raze. Women fighting, must be in your wheelhouse, right? Anyone following the discussions know "not really", but conceptions are hard to change.
I also had fights in real life which I find distinctly non sexy. I came from a life of violence I have no desire to return to. In fact when I encounter people who press me for details and do get off on it, it makes me uncomfortable. In my opinion, the stuff I did and saw should horrify, not titillate. But end of the day, I have no control over what THEY feel. Much of my writing has violence in it and the assumption is by some that the violence is the attraction for me. It is in fact a means by which I can ride the emotional roller coaster that I enjoy. And its not real. In fact I find it absurdly exaggerated. If some don't like that ride, don't read it. And yes some may get enjoyment from it for a reason that bothers me, but I can't control that and still make it available for all. I know producers also get fan mail that they wish they didn't get or requests for customs that bother them. And really, if they are going to have that kink, I would much rather they filled it by reading something versus going out in real life and harming another living creature.
And like most fandoms there are as many motivations as there are people. Some like the body contact, some the competition, some (like myself) the emotions. None are inherently right or wrong (unless they are illegal). They are right for that person. Might not work for you but there is a lot of material out there. For myself videos leave me cold as opposed to the written word because of the emotional context. And I get much more out of it being an active participant via a roleplay versus reading an account so stories tend to also fall flat for me. In the end, I can't see why everyone's desires can't coexist.
Anyways sorry for the slight threadjack, wasteland. if someone wishes to continue down this discussion and not swerve the thread further feel free to message me.