As a mature (aka old) guy myself, I definitely favor matches involving older, thicker women. Exactly what age group fits the description of "mature" is a matter of debate. I've always said that I won't look at a woman who is younger than my daughter, and she's 41, so that definitely limits the field. Frankly, I feel like a creeper when I watch young women wrestle or catfight, so I keep that to a minimum. Now, seeing vids shot in the 70's is OK with me, because the women in those vids are actually my age. I think that the best we can hope for is women in their late 40's, or maybe a scripted fight with women in their early 50's.
In regard to Maylay, she was always my favorite, and I believe that we're the same age. She had countless scenario fights that she did for Crystal and a few unscripted fights at the Hellfire Club. In Vid Mag #13, she fights a woman named (I believe) Gabrielle in a motel room. Two great mature bods colliding in that one. Her last fight was against the venerable Vivian in Granny's Grudge. Malay was in her mid-50's and Viv was a bit older when that one was shot. Both women fought topless and should be proud of the shape that they were in. I think that both women found that, at their age, even a scripted fight was a bit too demanding, so neither has fought since. Those fights were my two favorites featuring Maylay. Some time ago, someone posted another Maylay fight that I hadn't seen before. I copied the link and kept in my files, but it doesn't work anymore. That would have ranked #3.
I think that the reason that there are so few matches involving older or mature women is that it's hard to find women that age who are willing to fight (or wrestle) and whose bodies can take it. I'm in excellent shape for someone my age, but there's no way that I could get on the mat with another guy and not pay for it for the next 3 months. That's just the way it is.
In scanning the Producers Section of this website, it seems that Catfight-Connection has some mature women working for them. In playing the teaser clips, it looks like they have a product that comes close to filling our dreams. I need to purchase some of their stuff and find out. Has anyone done so?