[arkhamknight]

Who wins

[millsman]

For a good picture of Hilary's arms just Google her in Hawaii on the beach. Several bikini shots from this last summer she's way more muscular than Kaley.

[fight_lover1]

Hilary is 5'2'', Kaley is 5'6'' ... Both are working out... I think Kaley could be more bitchy in a catfight and she has 4'' height advantage so I am going with her

Hilary,

Kaley


Hilary,

Kaley

[hackstar9]

I reallylike Hilary alot, think she very hot.  But Kaley very toned, strong and more aggressive.  Be a long tough match, but Kaley will talk Hilary in the end.

[DogWithABone]

For a good picture of Hilary's arms just Google her in Hawaii on the beach. Several bikini shots from this last summer she's way more muscular than Kaley.

Kaley is much bigger and trains MMA. She'd fucking destroy the lesser Duff sister.

[Sandman13]

I never really care who would win in real life. I just like to see Kaley get trounced and humiliated by other celebrities. Go Hillary!

[T aka Tony]

Have to go with Kaley, she loves the MMA scene.

[HumiliationOne]

Kaley would have so much fun with Hilary. No contest here. Only question would be how long Kaley would keep Hilary around and how she would take her out.  Id like to see her end it with head strikes.