SPOILER ALERT
I totally disagree Chantelle Fox was outmatched by Toony and that with natural boobs the result would be the same. Chantelle had won previous match and fought great against Toony. Although I agree she was surprised at the start by Toony aggressiveness she comes back and it was evenly matched till the big moment of the fight, when Toony grab and maul mercilessly Chantelle big boobs (the pain and surprise in her face is priceless). After that Chantelle grabbed Toony´s small natural boobs trying to inflict the same pain but at the end had to go for her wrists to stop the unbearable pain in her big boobs. Chantelle fought courageously and tried all but she simply couldn´t stand the pain in her fake breasts. I have more examples to think implants are a disadvantage in catfight:
Pandora from Catz Review is a fierce catfighter, we couldn´t say she is a pushover like Jasmine, she wins most of their matches and is ruthless in her fights, but she has a clear weakness in her gorgeous body, her big fake tits. She rarely goes for her opponent boobs but all her rivals have the same strategy: maul and twist those amazing fake tits. the pain is so big in some matches she can´t hide the screams of pain.
Mila vs Kat. I think Kat was undefeated at that moment and in my opinion was winning the fight against the great Mila till the first submission, a wild tit attack. After that Kat simply was too afraid for her big implants and the cruel Mila took advantage.
Mila vs Bella Ink. This is a totally one sided match, but with only one submission, a vicious tit attack that let Bella crying and holding her battered boob. Bella was outmatched but shows an amazing high tolerance for suffering, sadly the tit pain was too much for her, she even said to Mila openly crying: "let go of my titties bitch"
I´m a man so i don´t know anything about implants but these are to me various examples that lead me to think implants are a problem in a catfight. Maybe cause women know the girl anatomy and know how to use the implant to make damage, the fear to rupture them, or cause a rough maul can move the implant inside the breast.
In my opinion titfight is totally different and implants are a great advantage. An example could be Ebony Ayes. She has natural boobs so big and firm no one could even put up a fight, she completely destroyed glorious busty babes like Danni Ashe, Micki Marsaille or Kim Watson, but she has no option against Melissa Mounds horribly gigantic fake tits. I think it also depends of the operation, there are fake breasts that looks totally natural like Ava Addams (what a great surgeon) and could lose to natural. In a Bea Flora (to me the most perfect tits ever) vs Ava Addams probably the amazingly firm boobs of bea would destroy Ava´s fake globes.