Does it have to be women from the same era?
Nope
In that case Kate Beckinsale. And as for does she win, well, that depends on how we define 'win'.
She dominates Kate in a rolling, hairpulling catfight. She's on top of Kate, pinning her down and crushing her beneath (while viciously tearing Kate's hair) for about 80%+ of the time. The remainder is split between furiously catballing around and Kate occasionally being on top. The latter doesn't happen often, anytime it does is brief, and even then Lynda still yanks Kate's gorgeous mane of hair mercilessly. Before proceeding to roll Kate off of her, onto her back, and pouncing on her to continue her relentless mauling and domination of Kate. All the while spitting venom and hatred at beautiful Kate.
Only thing is though because Kate is so incredible she bravely refuses to concede. She's fighting for her man and won't give him up for any reason, no matter what cruelty she must endure. Every time Lynda demands Kate submit she is met with a defiant "fuck you!!" or 'fucking bitch!!" etc.
That's how I see it anyway.
