I absolutely agree with you. To me in order of importance:
- At least one of the combatants must be attractive. There are a lot of big fat ugly women fighting in youtube that are unwatchable.
- Women fight like "women". If one is a professional fighter i dont like it, its like Sarah Brooke, she was amazing at first but then she learns and practice movements and her fights are mostly bored.
- Build up. When you know the reason of the fight and how they hate each other you can feel the tension, like two popular alpha girls who wanted to be the most popular desired girl in college, or the girl in a party that doesn´t care the man she likes has a girlfriend. DottiD is a master creating that build up in her stories. I also like those previous full of tension prefight moments taking off earrings or giving the purse to a friend.
- Spontaneous and real fight or spontaneously arranged: Two girls clash in a pub "Let's settle this out so the bouncers don't stop us" Nothing beats two hot girls dressed to kill leaving the pub to fight with all people behind to watch them.
- I also love scratching and hair pull, it shows the hate and evilness women have when they fight. I´d add going for the earrings and piercings.
I add some new things I like:
- Sexy feminine clothes like skirt, minidress, crop top, cleavage, etc.
- Rip out clothes spontaneously or purposely to gain an advantage, exposing the body and how they not prude continue fighting.
- Crowd. More people more tension and more transcendent the victory or defeat, even more if they know the fighters (classmates, coworkers, etc). I also like the friends cheering or insulting the rival.
- Humiliation end. The loser having to say "I give you are better, Im a loser, Im a bitch I´ll never flirt with your boyfriend again, etc", Slap and insult till cry. Leave the loser topless, or in a full nelson or camel clutch showing her breasts to the crowd, etc