If I may contribute a thought. Not as anyone who belongs to a clique of course ( being a man ) , and I can't say I am that familiar with who is in what group.
But your proposal is extremely well thought out and presented. I would only suggest an extrapolation of what you already suggested, that any fights...as many as possible, be public. Either in the chat room, or, following the excellent example set by Tinafights and Tonyacats ( and later with Alison ), a Yahoo conference chat setting.
It humanizes those who we may only see posting, and gives them a chance to really show off their cybering skills. In that instance , after years here, and in other catfight chat venues, watching hundreds of fights, it was very good to see a few ladies actually showing their skills and fighting talent. At this site through the years I'd attended or arranged countless fights in the chatroom but this was my first exposue to those from the forums . And in that instance both ladies seemed to enjoy the setting and the positive atmosphere.
It may not be possible but there are even some dynamic fighters in the chat as well who may enjoy the opportunity. After all, the top girl of FCF may well be someone in the chat who would take down anyone here

But no matter who participates, the more open and public matches the better. As opposed to just bantering.
Again, just two cents from an onlooker, best wishes to anyone who joins in , hope it turns out to be fun for all involved !